As a pontoon manufacturer and 3rd generation boat dealer, I can honestly tell you no matter what you do, you will NOT make paint stick to the toons. First tiny flake, scratch, or nick it will peel off almost immediately. Some of the companies I have dealt with have spent fortunes trying to make it work, and it just doesn't. Look at regency and Bentley. Shit tons of pissed off customers out there that can't keep the toons coated. The best alternative if you've got to do it is vinyl. Cheap and easy to replace when it gets damage or peels off. You really just want to do above the water line though. Trust me on this, been involved in this project many, many times.